Moral self-convictions: uncontested pleas and Canadian criminal law
Abstract
An uncontested plea allows criminal defendants to self-convict without requiring the state to prove its case against them. Uncontested pleas may be inculpatory, exculpatory, or non-inculpatory. Guilty pleas are inculpatory uncontested pleas. When a defendant pleads guilty sincerely, they formally take responsibility for the offence and accept the consequences. Exculpatory and non-inculpatory uncontested pleas include best-interest pleas like \textit{Alford} and nolo contendere pleas, respectively. When a defendant enters one of these pleas, they agree to self-convict without formally taking responsibility for the offence. Statutory language formally forbids exculpatory and non-inculpatory uncontested pleas like nolo contendere pleas in Canada. I argue that the legal and ethical objections to these pleas and plea bargaining generally in Canada are largely misplaced. Nolo contendere pleas open new avenues of plea bargaining for defendants and prosecutors to explore, creating new opportunities for certainty, factual accuracy, agency, and mutual advantage in otherwise highly adversarial proceedings. Although formally forbidden, defendants may still enter nolo contendere informally and surreptitiously. I conclude by arguing that these pleas be formalized and proposing ways to do so.
Collections
Related items
Showing items related by title, author, creator and subject.
-
Method in legal-ethical reasoning, the criminal lawyer's conscience, the client and the court
Brennan, Sean Campbell (2000-08-01)A legal-ethical dilemma occurs when two legal duties conflict or, in the alternative, when a legal duty conflicts with a moral duty. Such dilemmas are inherent in the current regime for lawyers governing legal ethics in ... -
Insiders in a deaf world, barriers for the deaf offender in the hearing criminal justice system
Bone, Tracey Anne (1998-07-01)This thesis explores the depth of the barriers faced by the deaf offender within the hearing criminal justice system. Six (6) respondents/informants were interviewed for this qualitative study with the assistance of a ... -
Women's needs/available choices, juxtaposing criminal justice response to wife abuse with women's words
Minaker, Joanne Cheryl (1998-05-01)The purpose of this work is to explore whether feminist engagement with the state and law to address the problem of wife abuse has produced benefits in the lives of women victimized by male inti ate violence. This study ...